Most underrated/overrated PF album ?

- petit_17 a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 12 mars 2010, 11h04m
underrated - Meddle and Animals

overrated - Dark Side of the Moon and The Wall

[quote][b][user]petit_17[/user][/b] a dit : underrated - Meddle and Animals overrated - Dark Side of the Moon and The Wall[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- Pie95 a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 17 mars 2010, 10h46m
Underrated - Meddle, Animals, Ummagumma and A Saucerful Of Secrets (many people don't like the last two because they're too much psychedelic)

Overrated - The Dark Side Of The Moon and The Wall (they're amazing, but people overrate them too much.

[quote][b][user]Pie95[/user][/b] a dit : Underrated - Meddle, Animals, Ummagumma and A Saucerful Of Secrets (many people don't like the last two because they're too much psychedelic) Overrated - The Dark Side Of The Moon and The Wall (they're amazing, but people overrate them too much.[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- RedSoxAshley a dit :...
- Abonné
- 25 mars 2010, 11h32m
From a merely merchandise point of view, overrated: Dark Side of the Moon. I'm sorry, but when walmart starts designing hoodies with Dark Side album art on it, with rhinestones directed towards tweens, its time to start slapping people. Plus, I'd really like a Final Cut hoodie. Haha.

Listening:
Overrated: None.
Underrated: The Final Cut

[quote][b][user]RedSoxAshley[/user][/b] a dit : [b][color=#206500]From a merely merchandise point of view, overrated: Dark Side of the Moon. I'm sorry, but when walmart starts designing hoodies with Dark Side album art on it, with [u]rhinestones[/u] directed towards tweens, its time to start slapping people. Plus, I'd really like a Final Cut hoodie. Haha. Listening: Overrated: None. Underrated: The Final Cut[/color][/b] [/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- [Utilisateur supprimé] a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 10 avr. 2010, 2h45m
Kretenos said:
Underrated - Obscured by Clouds, Atom Heart Mother

Overrated - Division Bell (Anything after The Wall isn't Floyd)
I agree with this.

[quote][b][user][/user][/b] a dit : [quote][b][user]Kretenos[/user][/b] said: Underrated - Obscured by Clouds, Atom Heart Mother Overrated - Division Bell (Anything after The Wall isn't Floyd)[/quote] I agree with this.[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- HamoMagicMan a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 10 avr. 2010, 15h47m
Underrated: Obscured by Clouds
Overrated: Dark side of the moon

[quote][b][user]HamoMagicMan[/user][/b] a dit : Underrated: Obscured by Clouds Overrated: Dark side of the moon[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- kirczek a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 11 avr. 2010, 21h37m
I don't feel like any of their albums is underrated but if I had to choose it would be Animals for some reason. ;p

[quote][b][user]kirczek[/user][/b] a dit : I don't feel like any of their albums is underrated but if I had to choose it would be Animals for some reason. ;p[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- samgmusic a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 15 avr. 2010, 4h28m
overrated: The Final Cut
Underrated: Obscured by Clouds

[quote][b][user]samgmusic[/user][/b] a dit : overrated: The Final Cut Underrated: Obscured by Clouds [/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- paradeda a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 17 avr. 2010, 20h41m
Underrated: Ummagumma
Overrated: Dark Side Of The Moon

[quote][b][user]paradeda[/user][/b] a dit : Underrated: Ummagumma Overrated: Dark Side Of The Moon [/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- Tiago999 a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 19 mai 2010, 17h58m
Underrated: Obscured by Clouds, definitely.
Overrated: As in an album that does not deserve the actual credit that it gets?
Hum... don't really know...

[quote][b][user]Tiago999[/user][/b] a dit : Underrated: Obscured by Clouds, definitely. Overrated: As in an album that does not deserve the actual credit that it gets? Hum... don't really know... [/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- the_davidtron a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 20 mai 2010, 1h13m
Underrated- Obscured By Clouds and Atom Heart Mother.
Overrated- anything after The Wall. The Final Cut, A Momentary Lapse Of Reason, and The Division Bell are absolute trash except for maybe a couple of songs.

[quote][b][user]the_davidtron[/user][/b] a dit : Underrated- Obscured By Clouds and Atom Heart Mother. Overrated- anything after The Wall. The Final Cut, A Momentary Lapse Of Reason, and The Division Bell are absolute trash except for maybe a couple of songs.[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- shigshaw a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 21 mai 2010, 17h28m
Underrated: Meddle, echoes is pure genius

Overrated: The Wall

[quote][b][user]shigshaw[/user][/b] a dit : Underrated: Meddle, echoes is pure genius Overrated: The Wall[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- [Utilisateur supprimé] a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 23 mai 2010, 5h18m
Underrated: Atom Heart Mother
Overrated: The Dark Side of the Moon... Mainly because if you ask any kid my age about PF they'd would be like oh ye that band with the Dark Side of the moon album.

[quote][b][user][/user][/b] a dit : Underrated: Atom Heart Mother Overrated: The Dark Side of the Moon... Mainly because if you ask any kid my age about PF they'd would be like oh ye that band with the Dark Side of the moon album.[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- shofman a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 24 mai 2010, 20h42m
I'd say Animals is underrated and ... darn, I truly can't name an album that is overrated. I mean, people often only know Dark Side of the Moon, but then again, it's a great album :)

NI!

[quote][b][user]shofman[/user][/b] a dit : I'd say Animals is underrated and ... darn, I truly can't name an album that is overrated. I mean, people often only know Dark Side of the Moon, but then again, it's a great album :)[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- BasketCaseBarbe a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 24 mai 2010, 23h37m
Underrated: Animals and Zabriskie Point

[quote][b][user]BasketCaseBarbe[/user][/b] a dit : Underrated: Animals and Zabriskie Point[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- cm813 a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 29 mai 2010, 4h13m
soundtrack to "More"

[quote][b][user]cm813[/user][/b] a dit : soundtrack to "More" [/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- pepganzo a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 29 juin 2010, 20h27m
Most underrated: Obscured by Clouds
Most overrated: Animals (just don't like it as much as the rest)

[quote][b][user]pepganzo[/user][/b] a dit : Most underrated: Obscured by Clouds Most overrated: Animals (just don't like it as much as the rest)[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- froginvasion a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 26 jui. 2010, 18h18m
dark side is amongst their best albums, but for me it is not that much better than say, meddle, or animals, two albums who are not really that well known.
same goes for the wall

[quote][b][user]froginvasion[/user][/b] a dit : dark side is amongst their best albums, but for me it is not that much better than say, meddle, or animals, two albums who are not really that well known. same goes for the wall[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- powr-toch a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 28 déc. 2011, 14h12m
Underrated : A Saucerful of Secrets and Obscured by Clouds

Overrated : Nope.

[quote][b][user]powr-toch[/user][/b] a dit : Underrated : A Saucerful of Secrets and Obscured by Clouds Overrated : Nope.[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- guto013 a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 5 jan. 2012, 5h17m
Underrated: Meddle, Atom Heart Mother, perhaps Obscured by Clouds
Overrated: The Wall

[quote][b][user]guto013[/user][/b] a dit : Underrated: Meddle, Atom Heart Mother, perhaps Obscured by Clouds Overrated: The Wall[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- AliceCB a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 6 jan. 2012, 6h26m
Underrated: The Piper At The Gates of Dawn
Overrated: The Wall

[quote][b][user]AliceCB[/user][/b] a dit : Underrated: The Piper At The Gates of Dawn Overrated: The Wall[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- Gitoor a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 10 jan. 2012, 21h49m
Underrated: Atom Heart Mother
Overrated: The Final Cut

[quote][b][user]Gitoor[/user][/b] a dit : Underrated: Atom Heart Mother Overrated: The Final Cut[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- username382 a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 13 fév. 2012, 1h06m
Underrated: Atom Heart Mother
Overrated: The Wall

[quote][b][user]username382[/user][/b] a dit : Underrated: Atom Heart Mother Overrated: The Wall[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- efekok a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 20 fév. 2012, 16h30m
Overrated: The Wall and The Final Cut , also they should be published as Roger Waters albums.

[quote][b][user]efekok[/user][/b] a dit : Overrated: The Wall and The Final Cut , also they should be published as Roger Waters albums. [/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- Sir-SadeQ a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 24 fév. 2012, 0h57m
Underrated: Animals
Overrated: The Wall

Just let me kill you for a while...

[quote][b][user]Sir-SadeQ[/user][/b] a dit : Underrated: Animals Overrated: The Wall[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- DeadKinks a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 26 mars 2012, 5h46m
Someone said: "I don't understand how anyone could love The Wall and not love The Final Cut... It doesn't make sense to me."

Well, my taste is completely different, but follows the same logics. I think The Wall is a good album, but nothing particularly special. And The Final Cut bored me to death for sounding so derivative from The Wall.

Overrated (in order of acclaim/merit ratio): The Wall, The Final Cut, A Momentary Lapse of Reason, Animals, The Dark Side of the Moon, The Division Bell, Wish You Were Here.

Underrated (same thing): UmmaGumma, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, A Saucerful of Secrets, Atom Heart Mother.

The others seem to get more or less what they deserve.

[quote][b][user]DeadKinks[/user][/b] a dit : Someone said: "I don't understand how anyone could love The Wall and not love The Final Cut... It doesn't make sense to me." Well, my taste is completely different, but follows the same logics. I think The Wall is a good album, but nothing particularly special. And The Final Cut bored me to death for sounding so derivative from The Wall. Overrated (in order of acclaim/merit ratio): The Wall, The Final Cut, A Momentary Lapse of Reason, Animals, The Dark Side of the Moon, The Division Bell, Wish You Were Here. Underrated (same thing): UmmaGumma, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, A Saucerful of Secrets, Atom Heart Mother. The others seem to get more or less what they deserve.[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer