I Find Pink Floyd Overrated and Boring

Discussions en cours

AxemRangers a commenté sur “What does "overrated" mean” (16)   juin 2011

NicolasCatalani a commenté sur “It's not just that I think they're overrated” (7)   mai 2011

little_raven a commenté sur “STFU” (14)   juin 2010

Diamond357 a commenté sur “Pink Floyd are a poor mans NWA” (12)   mars 2010

• little_raven

  >stupid artsy rock >mediocre idm >radiohead

  le mois dernier

• theleft

  >metallica >nine inch nails >foo fighters >daft punk

  le mois dernier

• JBThazard

  PF fans are a very specific kind of demographic. They emphazie emotion more than anything else in music, and it isn't emotion in general, it's this specific kind of pseudo-misanthropy in a lot of their lyrics. That's how mega PF fans relate to PF, through the words more so than the music. And while I don't think that's an invalid way of enjoying art, it makes the band's albums particularly The Wall extremely subjective and esoteric. Musically it has a lot of filler with maybe 4 good tracks because its priority is the message itself. So people who call PF genius tend to care more about a musician's articulation of intuitions and ideologies more than using music itself to carry across these and other ideas. I like PF, but I can't relate to them, nor do I find them musically groundbreaking save for some really clever recording/sonic techniques. [/my2cents]

  le mois dernier

• martyrofevil

  I listened to Dark Side of the Moon for the first time a few months back. Incredibly hard not to fall asleep. I thought progressive rock was supposed to be, you know, progressive.

  avril 2012

• ThrashZone666

  I like Pink Floyd, but their fanboys are retarded. they're good but nothing too amazing

  mars 2012

• LSamuelDawson

  This group! AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHA LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL LMAAAAAAAAAAAOOOOOOOO ROFL

  février 2012

• LuxusPL

  Charts sucks but it doesn't change anything.

  janvier 2012

• archenemy666

  Having said that, the charts aren't much better. [2]

  janvier 2012

• Rosnay

  i prefer polka

  novembre 2011

• jm_berserk2012

  genial xD [tengo una lista de bandas odiadas, aunque este no es el caso ._.]

  novembre 2011

• essebsirob

  sid wouldnt take an everydayjob

  octobre 2011

• loveandfear

  Having said that, the charts aren't much better.

  octobre 2011

• loveandfear

  I agree with the name of this group

  octobre 2011

• smwxs

  listen to the psych stuff before they sucked. win.

  août 2011

• SymbolicHuman

  lol @ this group

  août 2011

• ElHuevas1428574

  Pseudo-intellectuals, pseudo-intellectuals everywhere...

  août 2011

• LuxusPL

  V true

  août 2011

• aHeadOnTheDoor

  This overrated band has the most pompous, arrogant, disrespectful fanbase in the history of rock'n'roll.

  août 2011

• little_raven

  Guess I should create a group "Pink Floyd und sauerkrautrock sind boring" then

  août 2011

• ludicrousspeed

  i would actually rather listen to pink floyd than the top artists

  juin 2011