Should APC ever return....

Page 1 sur 21 2 Suivant

- sweetrevelation a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 31 jui. 2006, 5h43m
Should APC ever return....

If A Perfect Circle was to return and make another record as a band, what would you like to see?

Would you want the same lineup on Mer De Noms or Thirteenth Step? Maybe a mixture? Or maybe something totally different?...well, with Howerdel and Keenan of course.

As for the record, what would you be looking for when it comes to the sound of the record? Harder or melodic, themed or basic?

I guess I just want to know what other APC fans are looking for. I do hope they come back after Tool's done.

[quote][b][user]sweetrevelation[/user][/b] a dit : If [artist]A Perfect Circle[/artist] was to return and make another record as a band, what would you like to see? Would you want the same lineup on Mer De Noms or Thirteenth Step? Maybe a mixture? Or maybe something totally different?...well, with Howerdel and Keenan of course. As for the record, what would you be looking for when it comes to the sound of the record? Harder or melodic, themed or basic? I guess I just want to know what other APC fans are looking for. I do hope they come back after Tool's done. [/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- zinigor a dit :...
- Abonné
- 31 jui. 2006, 6h52m
Same here! I really hope to see another APC album! But I'd rather hear it done with their last lineup. I agree that Maynard and Billy form most of the sound, but eMOTIVe's sound had some magical quality to it.

But regardless of the lineup, I guess, if there's another album by A Perfect Circle to be, I'm sure it would be at least as good as every other one out there. You could tell it by how Maynard evolves his art along with Tool and all his side-projects.

"Oh, sorry, I was taking life seriously!"
- Bill Hicks

[quote][b][user]zinigor[/user][/b] a dit : Same here! I really hope to see another APC album! But I'd rather hear it done with their last lineup. I agree that Maynard and Billy form most of the sound, but [album artist=A Perfect Circle]eMOTIVE[/album]'s sound had some magical quality to it. But regardless of the lineup, I guess, if there's another album by [artist]A Perfect Circle[/artist] to be, I'm sure it would be at least as good as every other one out there. You could tell it by how Maynard evolves his art along with [artist]Tool[/artist] and all his side-projects. [/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- [Utilisateur supprimé] a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 6 août 2006, 20h55m
I just hope they do not cover a song ever again. Other than that, I would love for them to come back.

[quote][b][user][/user][/b] a dit : I just hope they do not cover a song ever again. Other than that, I would love for them to come back.[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- A3nimic a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 8 août 2006, 2h12m
MrArtichoke said:
I just hope they do not cover a song ever again. Other than that, I would love for them to come back.
agrees with that!

i wish the Mer De Noms line-up comes back though...that line-up was great...particularly coz Paz was in it...but Troy is also a great 90s rhythm guitarist...so i would like to see Mer De Noms's lineup to make a comeback...James Iha is impressive but too lonely...and Jeordie(sp?) White is cool but i still prefer Paz to be in the lineup...

puresinner
[URL= http://www.youtube.com/user/aenimicvids]aenimicvids

[quote][b][user]A3nimic[/user][/b] a dit : [quote][b][user]MrArtichoke[/user][/b] said: I just hope they do not cover a song ever again. Other than that, I would love for them to come back.[/quote] agrees with that! i wish the Mer De Noms line-up comes back though...that line-up was great...particularly coz Paz was in it...but Troy is also a great 90s rhythm guitarist...so i would like to see Mer De Noms's lineup to make a comeback...James Iha is impressive but too lonely...and Jeordie(sp?) White is cool but i still prefer Paz to be in the lineup...[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- zinigor a dit :...
- Abonné
- 8 août 2006, 7h12m
MrArtichoke said:
I just hope they do not cover a song ever again. Other than that, I would love for them to come back.

Why not? Their covers were very interesting, I liked When The Leeve Breaks, Imagine and Let's Have A War very much!!

A3nimic said:
i wish the Mer De Noms line-up comes back though...that line-up was great...particularly coz Paz was in it...but Troy is also a great 90s rhythm guitarist...so i would like to see Mer De Noms's lineup to make a comeback...James Iha is impressive but too lonely...and Jeordie(sp?) White is cool but i still prefer Paz to be in the lineup...

Yeah, Paz kicked ass! I love the trick with her hair she does on the clip Judith. Awesome!

"Oh, sorry, I was taking life seriously!"
- Bill Hicks

[quote][b][user]zinigor[/user][/b] a dit : [quote][b][user]MrArtichoke[/user][/b] said: I just hope they do not cover a song ever again. Other than that, I would love for them to come back.[/quote] Why not? Their covers were very interesting, I liked [track artist=A Perfect Circle]When The Leeve Breaks[/track], [track artist=A Perfect Circle]Imagine[/track] and [track artist=A Perfect Circle]Let's Have a War[/track] very much!! [quote][b][user]A3nimic[/user][/b] said: i wish the Mer De Noms line-up comes back though...that line-up was great...particularly coz Paz was in it...but Troy is also a great 90s rhythm guitarist...so i would like to see Mer De Noms's lineup to make a comeback...James Iha is impressive but too lonely...and Jeordie(sp?) White is cool but i still prefer Paz to be in the lineup...[/quote] Yeah, Paz kicked ass! I love the trick with her hair she does on the clip [track artist=A Perfect Circle]Judith[/track]. Awesome![/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- [Utilisateur supprimé] a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 8 août 2006, 22h03m
zinigor said:

MrArtichoke said:
I just hope they do not cover a song ever again. Other than that, I would love for them to come back.

Why not? Their covers were very interesting, I liked When The Leeve Breaks, Imagine and Let's Have A War very much!!

A3nimic said:
i wish the Mer De Noms line-up comes back though...that line-up was great...particularly coz Paz was in it...but Troy is also a great 90s rhythm guitarist...so i would like to see Mer De Noms's lineup to make a comeback...James Iha is impressive but too lonely...and Jeordie(sp?) White is cool but i still prefer Paz to be in the lineup...

Yeah, Paz kicked ass! I love the trick with her hair she does on the clip Judith. Awesome!
The only cover I liked was The Nurse Who Loved Me.

[quote][b][user][/user][/b] a dit : [quote][b][user]zinigor[/user][/b] said: [quote][b][user]MrArtichoke[/user][/b] said: I just hope they do not cover a song ever again. Other than that, I would love for them to come back.[/quote] Why not? Their covers were very interesting, I liked [track artist=A Perfect Circle]When The Leeve Breaks[/track], [track artist=A Perfect Circle]Imagine[/track] and [track artist=A Perfect Circle]Let's Have a War[/track] very much!! [quote][b][user]A3nimic[/user][/b] said: i wish the Mer De Noms line-up comes back though...that line-up was great...particularly coz Paz was in it...but Troy is also a great 90s rhythm guitarist...so i would like to see Mer De Noms's lineup to make a comeback...James Iha is impressive but too lonely...and Jeordie(sp?) White is cool but i still prefer Paz to be in the lineup...[/quote] Yeah, Paz kicked ass! I love the trick with her hair she does on the clip [track artist=A Perfect Circle]Judith[/track]. Awesome![/quote] The only cover I liked was The Nurse Who Loved Me.[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- Luneva a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 10 août 2006, 12h32m
MrArtichoke said:
I just hope they do not cover a song ever again. Other than that, I would love for them to come back.

agreed, i'll be happy with anything as long as it's not another emotive (i almost never listen to that album).

[quote][b][user]Luneva[/user][/b] a dit : [quote][b][user]MrArtichoke[/user][/b] said: I just hope they do not cover a song ever again. Other than that, I would love for them to come back.[/quote] agreed, i'll be happy with anything as long as it's not another emotive (i almost never listen to that album). [/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- Hey-Ho a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 19 déc. 2006, 19h10m
Should APC ever return....
-YES

with Maynard, Billy (of course)
and maybe Jeordie W. and Josh F. or Jerome Dillon

-but this is a wish
which will never come true..

[quote][b][user]Hey-Ho[/user][/b] a dit : Should APC ever return.... -YES with Maynard, Billy (of course) and maybe Jeordie W. and Josh F. or Jerome Dillon -but this is a wish which will never come true..[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- Lenorelai a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 24 déc. 2006, 23h30m
APD of course should(I wished they return) return. And I don't care if it would be with covers, untill it would be wonderfull to hear, and something to fall in love with.

[quote][b][user]Lenorelai[/user][/b] a dit : APD of course should(I wished they return) return. And I don't care if it would be with covers, untill it would be wonderfull to hear, and something to fall in love with.[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- narrow a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 30 déc. 2006, 19h34m
apc not returning? i thought they would continue after a while again. i cant understand they dont.
the albums was made in a very short period and it seems they gained much out of it. it just seems so perfect?

but i really dont have a clue, do i?

[quote][b][user]narrow[/user][/b] a dit : apc not returning? i thought they would continue after a while again. i cant understand they dont. the albums was made in a very short period and it seems they gained much out of it. it just seems so perfect? but i really dont have a clue, do i?[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- aurifex a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 8 jan. 2007, 5h15m
I couldn't stand eMOTIVe for the most part. Mer De Noms and Thirteenth Step were on par, and although quite different, both offered an equal amount of awesome songs. I prefer Paz on bass though, I want her back. I think if they came back, I'd like to hear a mix of both albums.

Melodic: Blue, Vanishing, 3 Libras, Orestes, Gravity.

Hard: Judith, The Outsider, Pet, Passive.

Mystical: Magdalena, Thomas, A Stranger, The Noose

I wish Maynard and Billy would realize that Tool isn't half the band that A Perfect Circle was, and get back together with the original band lineup.

[quote][b][user]aurifex[/user][/b] a dit : I couldn't stand eMOTIVe for the most part. Mer De Noms and Thirteenth Step were on par, and although quite different, both offered an equal amount of awesome songs. I prefer Paz on bass though, I want her back. I think if they came back, I'd like to hear a mix of both albums. [b]Melodic:[/b] Blue, Vanishing, 3 Libras, Orestes, Gravity. [b]Hard:[/b] Judith, The Outsider, Pet, Passive. [b]Mystical:[/b] Magdalena, Thomas, A Stranger, The Noose I wish Maynard and Billy would realize that Tool isn't half the band that A Perfect Circle was, and get back together with the original band lineup.[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- noise_sound a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 12 jan. 2007, 9h44m
Lenorelai said:
APD of course should(I wished they return) return. And I don't care if it would be with covers, untill it would be wonderfull to hear, and something to fall in love with.

True the only time I listen to that album is when I listen to passive wich I think is one of their best songs ever. Though it's not really their song or what you should call it they really did a great thing with it.

[quote][b][user]noise_sound[/user][/b] a dit : [quote][b][user]Lenorelai[/user][/b] said: APD of course should(I wished they return) return. And I don't care if it would be with covers, untill it would be wonderfull to hear, and something to fall in love with.[/quote] True the only time I listen to that album is when I listen to passive wich I think is one of their best songs ever. Though it's not really their song or what you should call it they really did a great thing with it.[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- [Utilisateur supprimé] a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 19 jan. 2007, 21h58m
i'd love to see apc come back for one more album , i doubt it will happen though :\

[quote][b][user][/user][/b] a dit : i'd love to see apc come back for one more album , i doubt it will happen though :\[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- zinc_ukfr a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 21 jan. 2007, 19h16m
Despite their obvious differences, I can listen to Mer de Noms and Thirteenth Step back to back, since Over leads so perfectly into The Package. I would expect this other album to be different again, yet to keep this flow which the other two have (and naturally not another cover album, something of pure perfect circle-ness is needed). Whatever style though clearly they need to come back though ^^

-zinc ukfr-
The group for randomly staying up night for no apparent reason

[quote][b][user]zinc_ukfr[/user][/b] a dit : Despite their obvious differences, I can listen to Mer de Noms and Thirteenth Step back to back, since Over leads so perfectly into The Package. I would expect this other album to be different again, yet to keep this flow which the other two have (and naturally not another cover album, something of pure perfect circle-ness is needed). Whatever style though clearly they need to come back though ^^[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- Kobun a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 22 jan. 2007, 20h35m
If they returned..I'd smile for days!

I prefer the Thirteenth Step stuff to the Mer de Noms personally, but anoter album whatever the style would be awesome! So would be the following tour :P

[quote][b][user]Kobun[/user][/b] a dit : If they returned..I'd smile for days! I prefer the Thirteenth Step stuff to the Mer de Noms personally, but anoter album whatever the style would be awesome! So would be the following tour :P[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- Zyrak a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 26 jan. 2007, 12h28m
Can't understand that people are disliking Emotive. That album is their best album. Songs like Let's Have a War, People Are People, Imagine and Annihilation is godlike. =)

<2

Wubwubwub.

[quote][b][user]Zyrak[/user][/b] a dit : Can't understand that people are disliking Emotive. That album is their best album. Songs like Let's Have a War, People Are People, Imagine and Annihilation is godlike. =) <2[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- sweetrevelation a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 13 fév. 2007, 21h56m
I love Paz and would love to see her come back to APC if they return after Tool's done touring. I'm sure if she's not involved with touring, she'd contribute to the album's process =).

[quote][b][user]sweetrevelation[/user][/b] a dit : I love Paz and would love to see her come back to APC if they return after Tool's done touring. I'm sure if she's not involved with touring, she'd contribute to the album's process =). [/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- yyu-yu a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 1 avr. 2007, 12h49m
I want they to record another album. And it should be melodic and hard ;D with couple of quiet songs :P it should be a little different from other albums, but still have that apc sound. And I like their covers, they're really great. I don't know how can you don't like it :P:P

[quote][b][user]yyu-yu[/user][/b] a dit : I want they to record another album. And it should be melodic and hard ;D with couple of quiet songs :P it should be a little different from other albums, but still have that apc sound. And I like their covers, they're really great. I don't know how can you don't like it :P:P [/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- xthroughmyeyesx a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 2 avr. 2007, 5h55m
aurifex said:
I couldn't stand eMOTIVe for the most part. Mer De Noms and Thirteenth Step were on par, and although quite different, both offered an equal amount of awesome songs. I prefer Paz on bass though, I want her back. I think if they came back, I'd like to hear a mix of both albums.

I wish Maynard and Billy would realize that Tool isn't half the band that A Perfect Circle was, and get back together with the original band lineup.

I agree with all of that except the second paragraph, haha. They are two separate worlds and should be regarded as such, I feel.

[quote][b][user]xthroughmyeyesx[/user][/b] a dit : [quote][b][user]aurifex[/user][/b] said: I couldn't stand eMOTIVe for the most part. Mer De Noms and Thirteenth Step were on par, and although quite different, both offered an equal amount of awesome songs. I prefer Paz on bass though, I want her back. I think if they came back, I'd like to hear a mix of both albums. I wish Maynard and Billy would realize that Tool isn't half the band that A Perfect Circle was, and get back together with the original band lineup.[/quote] I agree with all of that except the second paragraph, haha. They are two separate worlds and should be regarded as such, I feel. [/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- atomowa_zabawka a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 4 avr. 2007, 21h19m
My dream was to see them on the stage. I hope they'll return, but... not with covers, like on eMotive. I really do not like it.

~size matters?

[quote][b][user]atomowa_zabawka[/user][/b] a dit : My dream was to see them on the stage. I hope they'll return, but... not with covers, like on eMotive. I really do not like it.[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- plastic_christ a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 13 jui. 2009, 21h40m
I didn't mind the covers on Emotive at all as it was all part of a theme (war, peace, etc) . The covers were good too and not like standard same-y covers.

If they ever did return I wouldn't mind who was in the band along with Maynard aslong as Josh Freese was still drumming.

Be cool to see something different or on another level from Thirteenth Step.

[quote][b][user]plastic_christ[/user][/b] a dit : I didn't mind the covers on Emotive at all as it was all part of a theme (war, peace, etc) . The covers were good too and not like standard same-y covers. If they ever did return I wouldn't mind who was in the band along with Maynard aslong as Josh Freese was still drumming. Be cool to see something different or on another level from Thirteenth Step.[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- neudera a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 4 oct. 2009, 8h45m
All I care about is if Maynard, Billy, Paz, and John return.

[quote][b][user]neudera[/user][/b] a dit : All I care about is if Maynard, Billy, Paz, and John return.[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- DWarsong a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 7 oct. 2009, 13h03m
Agree with dont cover again.. BUT we got fucking Passive at least!!

"Everyone wants to be centre of the Universe-but no one truly is.." - DWarsong

[quote][b][user]DWarsong[/user][/b] a dit : Agree with dont cover again.. BUT we got fucking Passive at least!![/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- bluedisposition a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 14 déc. 2009, 2h36m
I don't care that much about the line-up because I like both of them, I just hope they will continue to make beautiful and unique music. In a recent interview Maynard said that he will hopefully be working with Billy on some new APC songs during the next year. I can't wait to hear what they will come up with this time :)

Watch the weather change....

[quote][b][user]bluedisposition[/user][/b] a dit : I don't care that much about the line-up because I like both of them, I just hope they will continue to make beautiful and unique music. In a recent interview Maynard said that he will hopefully be working with Billy on some new APC songs during the next year. I can't wait to hear what they will come up with this time :)[/quote]

Lien permanent Citer
- MP3_1986 a dit :...
- Utilisateur
- 22 jui. 2010, 6h05m
Of course A Perfect Circle should return; there's no debate there. As for who should be in the band line-up, I consider Paz a staple in the group. As long as they have Josh, Billy, Maynard and Paz, they can welcome anyone else who fits the role well. New is a good thing. I don't really expect Paz to join again, but I'd certainly love it.

[quote][b][user]MP3_1986[/user][/b] a dit : Of course A Perfect Circle should return; there's no debate there. As for who should be in the band line-up, I consider Paz a staple in the group. As long as they have Josh, Billy, Maynard and Paz, they can welcome anyone else who fits the role well. New is a good thing. I don't really expect Paz to join again, but I'd certainly love it. [/quote]

Lien permanent Citer